Spoiler Alert: This post discusses two
popular books, Defending Jacob and Gone Girl. While it is not my
intention to reveal too much about their endings, if you have not
read them, you might want to skip this.
A long time ago a writing teacher told
me to trust my readers' intelligence. He said that not every end has
to be tied up and not every thing has to be neat and tidy as long as
there is a sense of satisfaction at the end of the book. I have
thought of this often both as a writer and as a reader. There have
been times when reader reviews of some of my work find the ending too
ambiguous – of course there have also been a good many times when
reader reviews loved those very same endings. Recently I finished two
very popular, mainstream novels that both had ambiguous endings but
that left me with very, very different reactions.

Both of the books had at their core a
husband and wife relationship. In Gillian Flynn's Gone Girl the
couple is Nick and Amy, they have been married for awhile but do not
have children but are hoping to have one. In William Landay's
Defending Jacob the couple is Andy and Laurie who are the parents of
14 year old Jacob. Both books are very well written with plenty of
suspense and lots of twists and turns. Both of them concern the
commission of a crime and the legal proceedings and investigation
around those crimes. Both have endings that leave you guessing, and
both of them haunted me for long time – but for very different
reasons – one good, on less so.
In Defending Jacob, attorney Andy
Barber is a good man who has lived his life trying to be an honorable
and decent husband, father and lawyer and has kept secret that he is
descended from a line of very disreputable fore-fathers. His own
father is serving a life-sentence in prison for murder, a fact which
he had always kept from his wife and son. When a classmate of Jacob's
is found murdered in a nearby park, Jacob is suspected and, as the
story unfolds and as secrets are revealed, we find out that Any isn't
the only one with secrets. Jacob has long been the victim of bullying
and he has some vary unsavory habits of his own.

In Gone Girl Nick and Amy are a
successful young couple who long to have a baby but, on the their
fifth anniversary, Amy mysteriously disappears and Nick is quickly
suspected of foul play. The story unfolds through a series of diary
entries that present Amy as a sweet, trusting, and loving wife while
Nick is a self-absorbed womanizer who was cheating on her. This story
moves at a much faster pace than does Defending Jacob and had me
nearly breathless at times.
Now, here's the thing. As we begin to
learn more about Amy and she becomes increasingly complex and
devious, while Nick becomes increasingly dislikable and devious. As
we learn more about Andy and Laurie, Andy has some problems (not the
least of which is his murderer father) but his loyalty to his son and
his wife seems a bit naïve but admirable, while Laurie's inability
to trust her son and to be overly trusting of the psychiatrist who is
evaluating him becomes more annoying. I had a hard time liking Laurie
after her first interview with the psychiatrist in which she seemed
nearly hell-bent on proving that Jacob was a psychopath. I believed
her – I just didn't like her.
I won't go in to the details but both
books end with the couples fully aware of the weaknesses of one
another and their relationships forever altered by what has happened.
In the case of Andy and Laurie, while I was disturbed by the
implications and possibilities, I understood why what happens
happened. The entire story built to the ending and it could not have
ended any other way. With Nick and Amy I felt quite the opposite.
While I didn't like either of them and felt they probably deserved
each other I thought the ending was a cop-out – like the author had
painted herself into such a clever corner that she couldn't figure
out how to get out of it so she just quit writing.
What's the difference? For me I felt it
was all in the build-up. Plotting is tricky and a skill that takes a
lot of finesse. In Defending Jacob everything in the plot built
toward an inevitable result. In Gone Girl everything in the plot
seemed to build toward an inevitable result that never materialized.
Of course these are just my opinions but I was fascinated with how
different I felt toward both ambiguous endings. I recommend both
books. I gave both of them good reviews . But I was left feeling
that, while I would trust Landry enough to want to read more of his
books, I did not feel that way about Flynn.
Thanks for reading.